unconstitutionality of the Municipal Bill n.º 11.862/25 of Belo Horizonte

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.30749/2177-8337.v31n65p74-89

Abstract

This article examines the unconstitutionality of Municipal Bill n.º 11.862/25 of Belo Horizonte, which authorizes the use of the Holy Bible as a teaching aid in public and private schools. The analysis is based on constitutional doctrine, Supreme Federal Court jurisprudence, and contributions from political philosophy, especially John Rawls’ concept of public reason. It argues that the law is formally unconstitutional by encroaching on the Union’s exclusive competence to legislate on educational guidelines (art. 22, XXIV, Federal Constitution) and by failing to comply with the constitutional requirements for creating public expenditures established in art. 113 of the ADCT. The article also contends that the law is materially unconstitutional for violating the principle of state secularism (art. 19, I, Federal Constitution) by privileging a specific religious tradition and imposing its presence in secular disciplines such as History, Philosophy, Literature, and Arts. The mandatory wording, evident in the verb “shall” (“deverão”), reveals that the measure goes beyond cultural inclusion and enforces a religious bias in the curriculum. It concludes that the law threatens core values of the Democratic State of Law and must be declared unconstitutional to ensure that public education remains a space for citizenship formation rather than religious indoctrination.

Author Biography

  • Lucas Porto Foppa

    Mestre em Filosofia (UFRGS). Bacharel em Ciências Jurídicas e Sociais – Direito Noturno (UFRGS), com láurea acadêmica. Orientando do Prof. Dr. Paulo Baptista Caruso Macdonald (UFRGS).  Técnico Administrativo da Defensoria Pública do Estado do Rio Grande do Sul (DPE-RS). E-mail para contato com o autor: <lucas.p.foppa@gmail.com>.

Published

2026-08-04