THE OBSTACLES TO THE EXERCISE OF CONSTITUTIONAL JURISDICTION AND THE WAY GIVEN BY THE PUBLIC HEARINGS

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.30749/2177-8337.v23n45p61-76

Keywords:

New constitutionalism, Judicial review, Public hearings, Federal Supreme Court

Abstract

The present paper analyses the new constitutionalism`s contribution to the judicial review realized by the Federal Supreme Court (STF), from two of its de essential features: the normative force of the constitutional text and the law`s constitutionalization. Starting from the new constitutionalism`s theory explored by Luís Roberto Barroso, investigated the difficulties, of scientific and political feature, that are present in judicial review as consequences of the Constitution`s reinforcement, that makes the Constitution not only a political document, but also an important legal instrument. The search is qualitative and resorts of some punctual judgements of STF, marked by the convocation of public hearings, in order to analyse how this mechanism serves to the Court`s Justices, since they are increasingly deciding about matters of which they are not constantly aware. Besides evaluate the public hearings as a mechanism that attempts to overcome the lack of scientific knowledge about some themes, it is investigated, at the same way, how they are called, with the intention to surmount political obstacles to be trespassed, especially in processes that have big repercussions, in wich it is questioned if the Federal Supreme Court, as the house of the Judiciary, would have legitimacy to decide.

Published

2019-07-23